Thoughts on reading Barth (C. D. I-2, p. 304)
".. Yahweh is not zealous against (idols) only for the sake of His own honor, because He is the one God of the people of Israel. On the contrary, they are "other" (Isa. 44:9ff) and "strange" first of all to Himself. They are of a different nature and kind. And for this reason, that they can have such representatives and substitutes in the images which are made by human hands, whereas He, Yahweh, cannot be rrepresented by any human work. For His name is Holy. .... "
Barth is on to something here. God is not threatened by competition with 'other gods'... whatever man attributes to such beings is simply a reflection of his own present interests and hungers. Man is threatened by the vagaries of agricultural production, war, fertility, etc. and he fashions images or statues that provide an outlet for those things. God is not immediately threatened by this... for they reflect man's ignorance of His own Person and Sovereignty. It is when man presumes to erect idols representing Himself or the occupants of His Heaven that God takes fierce umbrage.
How arrogant of man to think that He can "create" anything to accurately express fundamental truths transcendent to himself and all creation. What handiwork of his could reflect the "otherness" of God? Even the glorious angels are not accessible to him. Man must receive whatever knowledge of God and heavenly things as he can assimilate as a child receives milk from his nursing mother. Apart from God reaching out to us we are blind and dumb and lame. We are not only lacking in knowledge we are physically, spiritually and emotionally impaired.
(Joh 3:6 NKJ) " 6 "That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit."
God stands above man and calls him to knowledge of Himself... from that awakening, all of which is God's initiative, man first is able to have even a glimmer of true light shining in his life. From that point all that was "old" now becomes tawdry and cheap in comparison. What matter is the "new", the joyous discovery of the Kingdom that was hidden but present all along. There is first the cringing shame of self-discovery, the awareness of sin. Then there is the incredulous news that those sins are not only forgiven but washed away through the blood of Christ and then, in crowning trumpet sounds, the glorious news that he is adopted as a son (or daughter) and is a joint-heir with Christ.
What of man's hands could do justice to this? All our best works are nothing but caricatures communicating error more than truth. But the Gospel... the Word of God which is the Kingdom of God and its King... that is all.
1 Samuel 12: What Could Be More Reasonable?
Image: Color Textures, 2019, Lancaster Co., Pa
1 Samuel 12:6–7 (NKJV) 6 Then Samuel said to the people, “It is the Lord who raised up Moses and Aaron, and who brought your fathers up from the land of Egypt. 7 Now therefore, stand still, that I may reason with you before the Lord concerning all the righteous acts of the Lord which He did to you and your fathers:
1 Samuel 12:20–22 (NKJV) 20 Then Samuel said to the people, “Do not fear. You have done all this wickedness; yet do not turn aside from following the Lord, but serve the Lord with all your heart. 21 And do not turn aside; for then you would go after empty things which cannot profit or deliver, for they are nothing. 22 For the Lord will not forsake His people, for His great name’s sake, because it has pleased the Lord to make you His people.
On various occasions I review a bunch of my images to cull some to clear up disk space or for some other reason. As I do this I try to rate those the "keepers" and assign them a relative "value" from 1 to 5. At some point I will group the "5's" together, look at each individually and ask myself "Why do I like this one? What is it that makes it stand out from the rest, at least to me." I ask the same type of question to other people when they think one is really special. "What is it about it that makes it special?"
This has lead me to understand that there is much more to producing a good image than just "point and click." Not that I didn't already know this but it is an area where I am constantly growing. Photography, like any good art, is a "rational" activity. A person may pick it up intuitively and just "see" the image they want to record, certainly. But when that happens, even then, when examined it will be seen to conform to some general principles. In other words... there is method... order... intentionality... in the organization of beautiful things.
This is true even when there is apparent chaos at first impression. In the above image there is certainly chaos. But you might notice that I have tried to bring out the "primary colors" to produce internal contrast. Red & Green, Blue & Orange especially. Yellow is present but there is only a small bit of purple/violet. I did not see this when the image was first taken it was only in development that I brought it out, but .... that's photography.
The point of all that rambling was to illustrate that what is beautiful is, necessarily, reasonable. Method, order and intentionality are not opposed to impulsive intuition (which often is mistakenly taken to mean "creativity") but rather are the subjects which an intuitive person recognizes. Some people have to think their way to the final product. Others just "see" it. One is not better than the other and both can err. But, in the final analysis, "come, let us reason together..." is the lens through which that which is beautiful can be comprehended and understood.
I love this chapter in 1 Samuel. It is so full of pathos as old, tired Samuel is striving to establish his people on solid ground so that they may prosper before the Lord. Samuel saw, with divine insight, that a truly beautiful life in this world is not only possible but it is what God desires for His people. It is a life lived in community because beauty, as in the image, requires contrast, diversity, individual contributions to the final product. The idea that a perfect man/woman is like a solitary Greek statue - pristine and faultless - with nothing missing, is a completely pagan idea. God has designed mankind to not be "alone" but rather to live in blessed community with others. The "image of God" that He wants mankind to reflect is a corporate image, filled with many diverse colors and forms and productive in total of that "image" with each individual making a necessary contribution.
Samuel doesn't explicitly lay this out in this chapter but it is implicit in his appeal to Israel. "Stand still so that I may reason with you!" he says. "Come let me show you a beautiful picture. Look in your history! See your fathers, the corporate reality of Israel as it existed then, and look at how God treated you with righteousness and justice. Look at all the great acts that He has done. Let this image fill your mind!"
"Now, think rationally. What does this all mean? What elements comprise this 'picture' and how do they show us 'beauty?' Is it not this: That God has declared, for His own great name's sake, that you are His people? If this is true, is it not clearly reasonable, logical, that He will continue to watch over you and to form you into a people who truly shine more brightly than all the stars in the sky?"
"Form this image in your mind: see yourselves, as a community, serving the LORD with all your heart (vs. 20). Think of how life would flourish if you mutually help each other stay focused, that you restrain each other from going after empty things (vs. 21). Does it not stand to reason that God would so encourage you and strengthen you and preserve you that, in hind sight, all of the difficulties that you may encounter would be seen to make the overall picture even more beautiful?"
"Be reasonable... consider what great things He has done for you. What could be more logical that to fear the LORD and serve Him in truth with all your heart." (vs. 24)
What a beautiful picture of God's people is presented to our minds here. The greatest thing about it is that it is not "abstract" art like the image above... rather it is as concrete as our own lives and the fellowship of our congregations. They can be truly beautiful... if we just observe the structures or elements that contribute and lead to beauty.
Posted by Gadfly on October 30, 2019 at 11:28 AM in Art, Christian Apologetics, Church, Commentary, Culture, Movies, etc., Devotional Meditation, Discipleship, Ethics, Personal Photography | Permalink | Comments (0)
Reblog (0) | | | |
| Save to del.icio.us